UKUSCompare & scanWhat we found

Shelf Check US › Cookies

The best cookies in US grocery stores, ranked

We ranked 12,489 cookies sold in the US using the Nutrition Facts panel and ingredients each brand gave to the USDA. Of these, 48% are high in added sugars per serving, 27% are high in saturated fat per serving, 18% use artificial colors and 20% list high-fructose corn syrup. The typical one has 4.7g protein, 32.3g added sugars and 286 mg sodium per 100g.

12,489cookies compared
48%high in added sugars per serving
18%use artificial colors
4.7gtypical protein per 100g

Jump to: Lowest added sugar · Lowest saturated fat · Highest-fiber · Lowest-calorie · All 12,489 cookies with full nutrition

The short answer

Lowest added sugar cookies

Ranked by added sugars per 100g out of 5,611 cookies whose label adds up. At most two per brand.

#ProductAdded sugars per 100gPer serving (FDA-style)
1Sf Peanut Butter Wafer, Peanut ButterVoortman Bakery · 9 oz (255 g)0g0g per servingSat fat MedSodium LowAdded sugars Low
2Sugar Free Wafers, VanillaEatz · 6.8 oz (194 g)0g0g per servingSat fat HighSodium LowAdded sugars Low
3Fudge Striped Shortbread Cookies, Fudge StripedVoortman Bakery · 11.3 oz (320 g)0g0g per servingSat fat MedSodium LowAdded sugars Low
4Sugar Free Chocolate Wafer Cookies, ChocolateGastone Lago · 7.5 oz (213 g)0g0g per servingSat fat HighSodium LowAdded sugars Low
5Chocolate Chip Cookies, Chocolate ChipMurray · 8.8 oz (249 g)0g0g per servingSat fat MedSodium MedAdded sugars Low
6Old El Paso Gluten-Free Crunchy Taco ShellsOld El Paso0g0g per servingSat fat MedSodium MedAdded sugars Low
7Old El Paso Stand 'n Stuff Crunchy Taco Shells 10 CountOld El Paso0g0g per servingSat fat MedSodium MedAdded sugars Low
8Original Almond + Coconut Creamer, OriginalNutpods0g0g per servingSat fat LowSodium LowAdded sugars Low
9Paleo Protein PowderPaleo Pro · 16 oz (454 g)0g0g per servingSat fat LowSodium LowAdded sugars Low
10Fruity Post Workout Recovery Iowhey Protein Strength Cereal, FruityPerformix · 16.9 oz (479 g)0g0g per servingSat fat LowSodium MedAdded sugars Low

Lowest saturated fat cookies

Ranked by saturated fat per 100g out of 11,484 cookies whose label adds up. At most two per brand.

#ProductSaturated fat per 100gPer serving (FDA-style)
1Maamoul Shortbread Cookies Made With Real Date Filling, MaamoulPalm Date Valley · 16.9 oz (480 g)0.1g0g per servingSat fat LowSodium LowAdded sugars Low
2Milk Candy WafersDulceria La Napolitana · 3.2 oz (90 g)0.4g0.4g per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
3Red Velvet CookieFood 4 Less · 11 oz (311 g)0.6g0.5g per servingSat fat LowSodium Med
4Breakfast Cookie, Pumpkin SpiceErin Baker's · 3 oz (85 g)0.6g0.5g per servingSat fat LowSodium Med
5Breakfast Cookie, GingerbreadErin Baker's · 3 oz (85 g)0.6g0.5g per servingSat fat LowSodium Med
6Tort WafersMarketing, Administration and Manufacturing, Inc. · 3.5 oz (100 g)0.6g0.2g per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
7Rainbow Chocolate ChipChoice Foods · 3.5 oz (99 g)0.6g0.3g per servingSat fat LowSodium Med
8Home Style Red Wine Biscuit, Home StyleHelaney's Food & More · 10 oz (284 g)0.6g0.2g per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
9Lambertz, Iced Gingerbread CookiesLambertz · 7.1 oz (200 g)0.7g0.2g per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
10Wafer Cookies, SesameHawaii Candy · 3 oz (85 g)0.7g0.2g per servingSat fat LowSodium Low

Highest-fiber cookies

Ranked by fiber per 100g out of 11,820 cookies whose label adds up. At most two per brand.

#ProductFiber per 100gPer serving (FDA-style)
1Protein Cookie, Chocolate ChipNo Cow · 1.8 oz (50 g)18g9g per servingSat fat HighSodium Med
2Protein Cookie, Double ChocolateNo Cow · 1.8 oz (50 g)18g9g per servingSat fat HighSodium Med
3Chocolate Chip CookiesTorn Ranch · 1 oz (28 g)17.9g5g per servingSat fat MedSodium Low
4Chocolate Chip Flavored Snack Protein Cookies, Chocolate ChipAtkins · 5.5 oz (156 g)17.9g7g per servingSat fat HighSodium MedAdded sugars Low
5Simply Almond Soft Baked Cookies, Simply AlmondMmmly · 5.5 oz (156 g)17.9g7g per servingSat fat MedSodium MedAdded sugars Med
6Birthday Cake Protein Soft Baked Cookie, Birthday CakeBuff Bake · 2.8 oz (80 g)17.5g14g per servingSat fat HighSodium MedAdded sugars Med
7Double Chocolate Protein Soft Baked Cookie, Double ChocolateBuff Bake · 33.9 oz (960 g)17.5g14g per servingSat fat HighAdded sugars High
8Snickerdoodle Soft & Chewy Protein Cookie, SnickerdoodleQuest · 2 oz (58 g)17.2g10g per servingSat fat HighSodium MedAdded sugars Low
9Protein Cookie, Double Chocolate ChipQuest · 2.1 oz (59 g)16.9g10g per servingSat fat HighSodium Med
10Gingerbread DecoratePublix · 38.8 oz (1,100 g)16.7g5g per servingSat fat MedSodium LowAdded sugars High

Lowest-calorie cookies

Ranked by calories per 100g out of 11,981 cookies whose label adds up. At most two per brand.

#ProductCalories per 100gPer serving (FDA-style)
1Gourmet Raisin CookiesAvo's · 12 oz (340 g)250 cal25 cal per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
2Bakery Street, All Natural Wedding CookiesBakery Street · 10 oz (284 g)250 cal70 cal per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
3Butter Flavored Cookie, ButterMama Lycha · 5.6 oz (160 g)250 cal100 cal per servingSat fat MedSodium Low
4Gourmet CookiesBakery Fresh · 10 oz (283 g)250 cal70 cal per servingSat fat MedSodium Low
5Butter ShellThompson's · 8 oz (226 g)250 cal70 cal per servingSat fat LowSodium Low
6Chocolate Cookie Overload Apple, Chocolate CookieN/A · 13.5 oz (382 g)250 cal140 cal per servingSat fat HighSodium LowAdded sugars High
7Homestyle Biscuits, HomestyleBest Byet · 7.5 oz (212 g)256 cal110 cal per servingSat fat LowSodium MedAdded sugars Low
8Pumpkin Spice Sweet Biscuits, Pumpkin SpiceMama's Biscuits · 18 oz (510 g)259 cal220 cal per servingSat fat HighSodium MedAdded sugars Med
9Kid Cuisine Snack Stix Naturally Flavored Apple Cinnamon Filled Soft BreadKid Cuisine263 cal150 cal per servingSat fat LowSodium Med
10Ruggero's Bake Shop Party Assortment, 2.5 lbRuggero's Bake Shop · 40 oz (1,134 g)263 cal

Get shrinkflation alerts

One short email when we find products that got smaller or changed their recipe. Free, never sponsored, unsubscribe any time.

We'll email you a link to confirm. We use your address only for these alerts. How we handle it.

How these rankings work

Rankings use nutrition per 100g, so big and small servings compare fairly; the per-serving figure under each number is what the Nutrition Facts panel shows. The badges are our own Low / Med / High for saturated fat, sodium and added sugars per labeled serving, using the cut-offs in the FDA's proposed front-of-package "Nutrition Info box" (low is 5% of the Daily Value or less, high is 20% or more). That rule is a proposal and is not final. Products whose numbers don't add up (calories that don't match fat, carbs and protein, or sugars above carbs) are left out of the tables but are still in the full list. Data: USDA FoodData Central branded foods, release of 29 October 2026; each product's newest label on file. No brand pays to rank higher.

Shopping in the UK? See the UK version of this aisle.

Other aisles

YogurtsHighest-protein firstBreakfast cerealsLowest added sugar firstChipsLowest-sodium firstProtein barsMost protein per calorie firstPasta saucesLowest-sodium first